"Christopher West’s interview on ABC’s Nightline has sparked some terrific discussion on the Internet. An impressive amount of the interaction is intelligent and illuminating, even some of that which is seriously wrong. One of the better responses is that by Jimmy Akin of Catholic Answers and the follow-up comments to his blog.
Here, I want to offer a brief, partial, response to Prof. David Schindler’s assessment of West’s work. The fact that Nightline got a lot wrong about West’s work is not surprising. In fact, it is surprising how much it got right. Those of us who work with the media know that potential martyrdom awaits us at the hands of an editor. West has likely been suffering a kind of crucifixion over the past week. What is puzzling is that an influential scholar chose this moment to issue a sweeping, negative critique of West in such a public forum. I have great respect for the work and thought of Schindler and realize that it must be difficult to be on the receiving end of criticisms of the work of one of their most high profile graduates. I wish, however, he had found another occasion to express his reservations about West’s work.
I think we should be very careful in our evaluation of the work of someone who is on the front lines and who is doing pioneer work. Virtually every pioneering author and presenter has had severe detractors in his own time. Some of them have been disciplined by the Church and eventually exonerated. I would like to give examples and mention names, but I don’t want to ignite a firestorm of "how can you compare Christopher West to X, Y or Z?"!
I want to add my voice to those who are enthusiastic about the West/Theology of the Body phenomenon. I think it is important to keep in mind, as Akin does, who West’s audience is. It is largely the sexually wounded and confused who have been shaped by our..." (Continued here)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(199)
-
▼
May
(21)
- Happy Pentecost Sunday!
- My new blog: View From the Domestic Church
- Statement on Christopher West from Fr. Jose Granados
- From the Dawn Patrol..."In the last couple of days...
- Dr. Janet Smith chimes in on the Christopher West ...
- Face Book and the Pope
- In the news: Obama picks Miguel H. Diaz, Ph.D for ...
- "Angels of God"
- Christopher West and Dr. Alice von Hildebrand
- More on Christopher West...
- Vatican's approval of bishop's criticism of Presid...
- Pope: Bring the Gospel to the Internet
- Christopher West's theology in question by theolo...
- Pope Benedict and Face Book!
- Bishop John M. D'Arcy and Notre Dame graduation
- Fr. James's Sunday Homily
- Free download: Answering Angels and Demons
- Fourteen million in donations being withheld from ...
- Notre Dame speaks out!
- Pope Benedict arrives in Jordan
- Christopher West on ABC Nighline tonight!
-
▼
May
(21)
Popular Posts
-
Tomorrow on the feast of the Most Sacred Heart of Jesus we begin the Year of the Priest... "Vatican City, Mar 16, 2009 / 01:16 pm (CNA)...
-
DONNA-MARIE: Karen, it is my pleasure to interview you about your latest work within the book Style, Sex, and Substance: 10 Catholic Women C...
-
I recently had the honor and pleasure of speaking with syndicated radio host, speaker and Catholic author, Teresa Tomeo ( www.teresatomeo.co...
-
Embracing Motherhood: Our Lady's Protection: A Sacramental from our Church
-
Learn all about the Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe in La Crosse, Wisconsin from its Executive Director, Sister Christa Marie, F.S.G.M. at 7...
-
Archbishop Chaput urges believers to find 'new spirit of knighthood' :: EWTN News
-
I recently had the pleasure of interviewing author, Lisa Mladinich about her inspiring and very attractive and AMAZING catechist booklets. ...
-
DONNA-MARIE: Kevin, it is my pleasure to interview you about your new book: Faith at Work: Finding Purpose Beyond the Paycheck published by...
-
View from the Domestic Church: Tomorrow Morning's Radio Interview
-
Vatican City, Nov 22, 2009 / 11:05 am (CNA).- In his message on the Feast of Christ the King to the tens of thousands of people gathered on ...